The Development of Lyme Arthritis. Discussion – Part 3
In response to B. burgdorferi, in vitro and in vivo transcription and expression of MMP-9, but not its posttranslational activation, occurred in a CD14-independent manner. In contrast, Zhao et al24 demonstrated a requirement for CD14 in both the transcription and expression of MMP-9 in human macrophages and fibroblasts. Left unanswered because of differences in experimental design is whether CD14 has a species-specific role in posttranslational activation of MMP-9. One critical distinction between the two studies is that Zhao et al relied entirely on in vitro experimentation with immortalized human monocytic and fibroblastic cell lines (ie, U937 and ATCC SCRC-1042.2, respectively), whereas, in the present study, the role of CD14 in regulation of MMP-9 at the transcriptional, translational, and posttranslational levels was evaluated during natural infection, allowing for more complex interactions among the pathogen, a variety of host cell types, and the ECM.
Finally, a phenomenon indicative of fibrosis reported herein was greater collagen staining in the joints of infected CD14−/− versus CD14+/+ mice. Inflammation and fibrosis are two interrelated processes with intertwined signaling events, especially when elicited by infectious agents. As part of the tissue repair process, neutrophils and macrophages coordinate their efforts to clear residual bacterial components and effect removal of apoptotic and necrotic cellular debris from the site of infection. Chemokines, cytokines, and growth factors released by these phagocytes recruit lymphocytes to and activate fibroblasts within the inflammatory focus. In addition, the differentiation of macrophages into fibroblast-like cells called myofibroblasts occurs within these foci. Fibroblasts and myofibroblasts participate in the reconstruction of ECM by virtue of their ability to deposit collagen and secrete MMPs. Tissue repair, a highly regulated process, is subject to dysregulation in the prolonged presence of bacteria and cytokines. Perpetual TLR stimulation at sites of infection or noninfectious injury can amplify profibrotic signaling and engender fibrotic disorders. In renal injury and cystic fibrosis, excessive TLR2 signaling induces several fibrotic genes. The absence of CD14 on macrophages results in a 50-fold increase in B. burgdorferi–stimulated transcription of tlr2 and protracted surface expression of protein, which, in turn, is partly responsible for greater production of proinflammatory cytokines. The ability of macrophages to trigger apoptosis in myofibroblasts also may depend on CD14 expression. Thus, in its absence, extended survival of myofibroblasts and their accumulation within joints could contribute to greater collagen deposition in CD14−/− mice. Alternatively, the inability of spirochetes to induce inducible nitric oxide synthase in CD14−/− macrophages may be a factor because the absence of inducible nitric oxide synthase activity has been associated with greater transcription of collagen genes and higher collagen deposition.49 Although not significant, a trend toward higher transcription of collagen genes was observed in CD14−/− joints compared with those of wild-type mice. Considering the potential implications of greater deposition and/or diminished turnover of ECM, it is important to note that B. burgdorferi express decorin-binding proteins A and B, especially when they reside in the skin and joints where collagen content is high. Surface expression of decorin-binding proteins A and B anchors spirochetes to collagen and may facilitate their persistence in mouse and human joints. The ability of spirochetes to embed themselves in dense collagen bundles may offer protection from both antibodies and antibiotics. Putting all this information together, we can speculate that CD14 not only helps in the activation of MMP-9 necessary for degradation of existing collagen but also may limit the continued production of collagen. Control of these fibrotic processes by CD14 not only leads to higher neutrophil recruitment and clearance of spirochetes but also deprives B. burgdorferi of “hide-outs” within joints.
This study describes a previously unappreciated function for CD14 in bacterial clearance by regulating the extravasation of neutrophils into the joints of B. burgdorferi–infected mice. Although CD14 deficiency leaves unaltered the production of CXCL neutrophil chemoattractants and transcription of mmp-9 both in vitro and in vivo, a significant decrease in the pool of active MMP-9 occurs. The cascade effect of this reduction in MMP-9 activity was diminished turnover of ECM and generation of PGP, limited recruitment of neutrophils into the joint space, and impaired clearance of spirochetes. These findings raise the intriguing question of whether individual variation in the efficiency of neutrophil-mediated clearance of B. burgdorferi might underlie differences in the severity and/or duration of Lyme arthritis observed in the patient population. If such differences are responsible for the range of clinical presentation observed, it suggests avenues for the development of adjunctive therapy designed to augment host immunity, perhaps through small molecule–mediated enhancement of neutrophil recruitment.